City of Cairnholm Constabulary
Detective Department — Criminal Investigation
Case No. CVIII of 1886 — in the matter of the death of Colonel Cecil Cruikshank, of Cruikshank Manor Filed Tuesday, the 19th of October, 1886 Officer Inspector Ulysses Subject The Inspector’s Brief, being the solution of the case published the 18th of October

This brief names the killer in its first line. Readers who have not yet sat with the case are advised to withdraw.

Summary. It was Aziz, Mr Xerxes's man these nine years, and not for any wife's portion nor settlement but for the place in that house the marriage would have ended; here is how I came to it.

❦

The Reckoning. The Colonel was strangled by hand, in his own gun room, between the moment he dismissed the company at 8:40 and the one ring of his bell at 9:05. There was no cord and no weapon, which told me at once it was a thing done close and quick, by a man who had decided on it before he opened the door. The torn collar, the thread of dark wool caught in the stock, and the four scratches on the Colonel's hand all pointed the same way, and when I found a dark wool coat folded over a chair in the morning room, with its owner sitting the rest of the evening in his shirtsleeves and the left cuff torn at the seam, I had no further use for guessing. Aziz left the table at 8:42, the moment the match was announced, gave Mrs Gow a story about a cloth at 8:45, and did the thing in the twenty minutes that followed, setting the Colonel back in his chair and the glass down beside him before he came out again at 9:12 pleading the fires. He never touched the pistols. A soldier's habit, to leave a dead man's weapons as he found them.

The household's first thought, naturally, was money, there being a marriage proposed and a will unsigned, and I let the money suspects clear themselves in turn, which they did without much trouble. Nan was at the table carving from 8:40 to 9:15, under three pairs of eyes. Xerxes was disputing freight rates with Quill until 9:15 and then in Zane's sight on the terrace, the two of them covering him entire. Fifi was held in the kitchen over a burst sack from 8:35 to 9:18, Mrs Gow's own book vouching for it. Zane served and cleared in the dining room the whole evening, seen by the whole table at the hour the bell rang. Cousin R never left his chair, remarked upon for not once setting down his wine. Lavinia was gone under a minute for a shawl, and back at table well before nine. Quill argued freight the whole window through. Wat Frew was put from the house at 8:20 and drinking at the Dog and Gun from 8:35 before a dozen witnesses. Effie signed the stewards' book at Cairnholm at 8:10 and was never at the Manor at all. Not one of them had the twenty minutes required, and the unsigned will, on examination, bore on nobody's purse but sat waiting at the solicitor's as it had for five weeks, idle.

The true motive sat where the money did not. The Colonel was the architect of an arrangement I need not name outright; what Xerxes was to Aziz, and Aziz to him, is their own affair and none of this office's business to spell out, but it is my business to say that the Colonel's proposed marriage would have put a wife at Hartfield House and ended, by Michaelmas, a place Aziz had held there nine years. The Colonel had already had him put out of the Manor pew for it, seated him below Cousin R at his own table for it, and said at church, within six people's hearing, that the Hartfield arrangements wanted tidying. A man building the end of another man's whole household does not always reckon what he is building toward. The Colonel reckoned wrong, and reached his bell one ring too late.

I had nearly set this file down without it, but there is one thing more. Aziz did not hide the coat — he folded it, in plain view, over a chair-back, because he had already settled what he meant to do and only wanted his sleeve free for it. A man hiding evidence does not fold it neatly. That is not the act of a man covering himself; it is the act of a man who has already decided the cost is paid. It is, I think, the truest thing in the file.

The charge is laid against Aziz for the strangling of Colonel Cecil Cruikshank, the third this twelvemonth, by my count, and I have sent word to have him held at Cairnholm until the assizes. The house will want a new footman, I expect, before Michaelmas comes round at all.

Ulysses
Inspector of Detectives
file closed
The moral of Case the First Hundred and Eighth

Aziz left the table and went down the hall,
While the Colonel was rising to answer a call.
The collar came loose, and a thread found its way,
But the butler still polished the silver that day.
The moral, we're certain, is prudence and care:
Avoid private violence—unless it is there.

❦