City of Cairnholm Constabulary
Detective Department — Criminal Investigation
Case No. CIX of 1886 — in the matter of the death of Xerxes Hartfield, of Hartfield House Filed Monday, the 8th of November, 1886 Officer Inspector Ulysses Subject The Inspector’s Brief, being the solution of the case published the 7th of November

This brief names the killer in its first line. Readers who have not yet sat with the case are advised to withdraw.

Summary. It was the Colonel, and for the plainest of reasons: a man about to lose the only machine that kept his roof on will sometimes do murder to keep his hand upon the lever. He beat Xerxes Hartfield to death in the stable passage with a whip off the stable wall, the night before the deed dissolving their venture was to be signed, because he had already secured the venture's people to himself and believed, with the partner dead and unsigned, he might run the whole concern alone. Here is how I came to it.

❦

The Reckoning. The method wants little telling. At ten a note went up from the hall table, unsealed, folded, and Xerxes — a night-walker, as the house well knew — went out without remark. The stable passage is the short way from the gun room to the yard, and a man walking it in a temper need only reach to the wall for a whip; four of its fellows hung there still. He was beaten where he stood, in fury rather than design — the lash broke near the keeper, a lantern bracket was torn bodily from the brickwork in the struggle — and left exactly as he fell, one arm flung out, his hat filling with rain three paces off. Nobody had composed that scene. Nobody had troubled to.

I put by the readings that first suggest themselves, as one must in a house fond of blue stones and old grudges. Nan was under the tailor's eye in the gallery the whole while, with two footmen to swear it. Wat was audibly at war with the cook in the kitchen passage, four servants the witnesses. Cousin R was behind the screen, the tailor's hands on him, from five minutes to ten until twenty past — a span that covers the death entire. Aziz and Lavinia sat together in the small library from a quarter to ten; and in any case the stone that might have tempted a jealous man was left hanging on its chain, untouched, and the man who gave it had nothing to gain by its staying there. Effie was insensible in a chair in the blue room, found so by two maids who could not rouse her. Quill stood over a draught in the still-room under the housekeeper's eye, and no frightened man commits a loud beating in a passage with a draught yet in his hand. Each of these falls on an hour accounted for, which is the only thing that ever truly clears anybody.

The Colonel accounted for nothing. His movements from twenty past nine to near eleven rest on his word alone. His cuff was soaked to the elbow, though he claimed to have kept indoors; his voice was heard raised behind the gun room door at about ten. And in his coat pocket, unemptied, sat the letter from Messrs Dunnet and Hale confirming the deed engrossed and awaiting signature — upon which the warehouses, the ships, and the India correspondence would revert whole to Hartfield — and beside it, in his own hand, a list of the venture's clerks and agents and the Bombay factor, each name priced, and underneath it the words that all of these will stand with me. He had said as much publicly, more than once, at dinner tables in this county: that the venture was a machine, and a machine does not care whose hand is on the lever. He had simply arranged, privately, to be the hand. Nothing was taken from the body because nothing needed to be; the theft he had in mind was larger than a chain and stone, and he had already done most of it before the whip ever left the wall.

I had near forgot one thing, though it closes the matter rather than opens it. The mud at the yard door carried one set of boot-prints going out and the same returning; no man left that house and failed to come back. The Colonel stepped into the rain after the work was done, and in again, and rejoined the company near eleven as though the evening had asked nothing of him. It had asked a good deal. I have charged him accordingly — the third this twelvemonth, by my count, and I do not expect it to be the last I am sent to this house to write down.

Ulysses
Inspector of Detectives
file closed
The moral of Case the First Hundred and Ninth

The Colonel, in fury, made the stable-yard rain,
While Xerxes was summoned by note through the lane.
The horsewhip was lifted; the lantern fell loose,
And the household went on with its pudding and goose.
The moral, we trust, is to leave things alone—
A lesson the Club will forget by the stone.

❦