City of Cairnholm Constabulary
Detective Department — Criminal Investigation
Case No. CX of 1886 — in the matter of the death of Effie Strange, of Cruikshank Manor Filed Tuesday, the 9th of November, 1886 Officer Inspector Ulysses Subject The Inspector’s Brief, being the solution of the case published the 8th of November

This brief names the killer in its first line. Readers who have not yet sat with the case are advised to withdraw.

Summary. It was Lavinia Loveless, the medium who had sat at the Manor table every Sunday these eleven years, and she did it because the woman she had been fleecing under cover of the dead Mrs Cruikshank's voice had stopped paying and meant, within the week, to say so in print. Here is how I came to it.

❦

The Reckoning. The glass tells the whole of the method, once a man troubles to ask who held it and did not drink. It went round the table in a fixed order — the Colonel, then Cousin R, then Nan, then Lavinia, then Effie — and four people drank from it and took no harm whatever. Only one hand held it last before the dying, and that hand did not drink. Lavinia touched it to her lips, pled her fast, and passed it on; Nan, sitting at her elbow, noticed the level had not moved. A thing need not be clever to be fatal. It need only be done in the four minutes a woman is out of the room fetching her shawl, with a chemist's bottle already in her pocket and a decanter reduced to one stem by an accident belowstairs she had no hand in arranging but was glad enough to use.

The household's first thought ran to the obvious — that Effie, who lived on her laudanum, had got some from somewhere and taken too much, or failing that, that it was a matter of the will and Nan standing next in it. Neither holds a moment's weight. Effie had gone without her dose since Saturday, Quill having refused her for want of payment, and was shaking for want of it at table, not dosed to death by her own hand. The will has stood untouched four years, as the Colonel said himself that night at his own table, cheerfully, with Effie laughing beside him; nothing tilted for Nan that Sunday that had not been standing so for four years running, and in any case she drank from that glass herself, third in the order, and passed it along to Lavinia, not to the dead woman. The Colonel drank first from it and lived; his own bottle sat full to the shoulder in the sideboard where it had always sat. Cousin R drank second and lived, and spoke of a specimen he meant never to hurry — an honest enough account of a patient man with no cause to move quickly against anybody. Quill was at a confinement on Barr Street until past eight and came to the table after the glass had begun its round; he sat beyond Effie and it never reached him, and besides, it was her money he wanted, not her silence. The servants — Fifi at the broken crockery, Zane under Mrs Gow's eye at the sideboard, Wat kept to the scullery passage — none of them came near glass or decanter at any hour that signifies. A full house, and not one of them free to have done it, saving the one.

What stood behind it was plainer than the method, once the paper in the reticule was read properly. Effie had paid Lavinia two hundred and forty pounds across eleven months, in a column ruled out in her own hand, for sittings got up to speak in a dead woman's voice. She had stopped the Sunday before, ruled the account through twice, and written "no more" beside it; and that same evening, before the port was ever poured, she sat at the Colonel's table and announced, laughing, that she meant to write up the whole trade of mediums for the newspaper, playbill and all — Lavinia's old playbill, which Effie had found and framed as a joke not three days prior, not knowing or not caring that she held the woman's whole history in a gilt frame. Lavinia had come to Cairnholm at Effie's own age selling a face that stopped a room; she had made of Effie's suggestibility a quiet income, as somebody had once made an income of hers. The girl who laughed at the playbill was fast becoming the very thing the woman across from her had made of herself at twenty-three, and the woman knew it before the girl did. When the money stopped, that was a hardship. When the exposure was promised aloud, at that table, in that company, it became a necessity. She emptied the bottle under cover of a glass she had never meant to drink from, and left the evidence to point at a dead opium-eater's own weakness, not knowing Quill had turned her away the day before and so left her without the dose she was supposed, conveniently, to have taken.

I had nearly set this aside as closed before I troubled to ask Mrs Gow where the household's spare blue bottles were generally kept, and whether any had gone missing from the still-room that week. One had. It wants no more than that to finish the matter. I have charged Miss Loveless accordingly. It is the third this twelvemonth, by my count, and I do not expect it to be the last out of that house.

Ulysses
Inspector of Detectives
file closed
The moral of Case the First Hundred and Tenth

Lavinia raised the slender glass and wore a fasting air,
And Effie found the port had turned remarkably unfair.
The blue bottle slept beneath the seat, where no one thought to look,
While household talk continued, and somebody read a book.
The moral, we're certain, is caution at the board,
Yet we'll drink to good behaviour when another glass is poured.

❦