Being the daily record of

The Cairnholm
Murder Club

Case the First Hundred and Tenth

The Sunday Decanter

❦

Dramatis Personæ

the company assembled, in order of respectability

Colonel Cecil Cruikshank
a retired officer of choleric temper and fixed habits; his unsettled will keeps others attentive.
Xerxes Hartfield
a gentleman of great fortune and few explanations; the most untroubled diner at any table.
Aziz
Xerxes's companion, constant at his side; a fixture no one enquires into.
Nan Pringle
the Colonel's poor relation; pours the tea, keeps the accounts, misses nothing.
Cousin R
a guest of uncertain relation and impeccable manners; forever pressing his specimens.
Reverend Simeon Gaunt
a mortifying cleric; imposes penance and keeps to his own parish.
Dr Tobias Quill
a nervous physician and coroner; supplies the company its remedies.
Lady Lavinia Loveless
a faded actress turned medium; apt to let people rather too close.
Fenella Fifi and Zane Swain
a lady’s-maid who hears more than a servant ought, twin to a footman correct in all things and fond of the rules.
Captain Wat Frew
a sea-captain of elastic accounts; owed money by half the company.

And each of them had reason to wish the victim dead.

In Memoriam
Effie Strange
cleverer than the company finds comfortable, spendthrift, adored and exhausting; always short of money.
❦

Everything that mattered happened at a table where nobody was alone. Attend to the order of the glass, and to what did not go down in it.

The Cruikshanks' household came back from the kirk wet to the ankles that Sunday in November, and the ladies took themselves into the small drawing room at 7:30 to dry out and say nothing much. Dinner was called for 8:00, the table laid in the room beyond. By 8:40 Effie was dead at it, between the fish and the saddle of mutton, having drunk from the one glass of port that had been going round from hand to hand since they sat down. She set it down on the cloth, observed that the Colonel's port had gone bitter, and did not speak again.

There was one glass only, and that by misadventure. The decanter had come up on the tray with a single stem beside it, Fifi having broken two of the set that morning and been had up about it belowstairs. So the company had done what company does: each took a sip and sent it along, in a fixed order, the Colonel's right hand to his left — the Colonel, then Cousin R, then Nan, then Lavinia, then Effie. Four had drunk before her from that same glass and taken no harm at all.

Quill, who is coroner as well as physician, took the glass up, put his nose to it, and said that the port had been dosed with laudanum in a quantity no ordinary dose would account for. He said it quite plainly, and then sat down again rather hard.

Lavinia had held it last. She did not drink. She touched the rim to her lips, remarked that she had been fasting since noon for the sake of her instrument, and passed it on; and Nan, at her elbow, noticed that the level in the glass had not gone down.

Afterwards, in the small drawing room, a small blue bottle was found under the cushion of the window-seat — empty, unlabelled, the sort in which laudanum is dispensed to anybody who asks. Effie's reticule lay open on the seat beside it. In it were two pawn tickets, a card of Dr Quill's with a figure written on the back, and a folded paper in Effie's own hand headed "Monies paid to L. Loveless," with a column of dates running back eleven months and a total of 240 pounds. The last entry in that column was dated the Sunday before, ruled through twice, with the words "no more" set beside it.

At table, before the port came round, Effie had been in high spirits. She told the company she had been reading a pamphlet on the exposure of mediums, that the whole business was muslin and reaching-rods, and that she had a mind to write to the Cairnholm Courant about it. She laughed when she said it. Lavinia said nothing at all.

The decanter's history was short and well attended. Mrs Sib Gow, the Colonel's housekeeper, filled it herself in the butler's pantry with Zane standing by her the whole time, carried it up with the single glass at 8:00, set it at the Colonel's elbow, and did not leave the room again until the fish was cleared. The Colonel's own laudanum bottle, kept in the sideboard drawer for his gout, was found in its place and full to the shoulder. As for Effie, Quill said she had taken none that day: she had come to him on the Saturday wanting her usual and had gone away without it, having nothing to pay with, and she had been short-tempered and shaking at dinner in the manner of a woman gone without.

Of the three gentlemen most usually in the Colonel's orbit, none was within a mile of the Manor. Xerxes and Aziz dined at Hartfield House and did not stir from it, their household vouching for them; Gaunt preached twice at St Ninian's and sat up afterwards with a dying parishioner, in the family's presence until past midnight.

The small drawing room had held Nan, Lavinia, Effie and Cousin R from 7:30 onward. Effie went out of it twice, to the hall and back. Lavinia went out of it once, to fetch her shawl, and was gone perhaps four minutes.

Mrs Gow states that Fifi did not come above stairs between 7:00 and the alarm, being at the broken set and then at the dish-covers; that Zane was in her sight from the filling of the decanter until he took his place at the sideboard, where he carved; and that Wat stood in the scullery passage from 8:30 until the house was roused, having come up from the harbour as he does on Sundays. Quill himself was sent for at 7:45 to a confinement in Barr Street and came on directly, the midwife and the father accounting for him until he reached the Manor door at 8:05, by which hour dinner had begun; he was seated at the foot of the table beyond Effie, and the glass never reached him.

Laudanum, it should be said, is in everybody's cupboard in Cairnholm. The Colonel keeps it for his gout, Quill dispenses it, Wat lands it, Effie lived on it, and Lavinia takes it for the headaches that follow a sitting. The chemist on Barr Street sells it over the counter to anyone at all, in blue bottles without labels.

Lavinia has sat weekly at the Manor these eleven years for the Colonel's late wife, at two guineas the sitting, and has been in the house since Friday's. She keeps rooms in Cairnholm that she has lately been unable to keep paid. She came to Cairnholm at Effie's present age with a face that stopped a room, and sold tickets on it; playbills of that season are still in circulation, and Effie had got hold of one, had it framed as a joke, and had carried it about the Manor on Friday showing it to people. On that same Friday Effie had told the Colonel, in Lavinia's hearing, that his wife's voice sounded a great deal like a woman with a cold, and that she could do it herself for nothing.

Effie Strange was twenty-three, the Colonel's heir-presumptive, fond of him and owing money in four shops on the Row. Nan Pringle is thirty-one, nine years resident, quiet and useful and entirely unremarked, and would stand next after Effie. The Colonel's will stands as it has these four years and has not been touched; he told the table so at dinner, cheerfully, with Effie laughing beside him. Cousin R, who had spent the week arranging a specimen in his flower-book, spoke of waiting for a thing to come to its proper ripeness, which he said was never hurried.

The single glass stood where Effie had set it down, with the port gone to a dull red at the bottom, and the company sat on either side of it in their Sunday clothes, none of them touching anything. Outside the rain went on at the window. In the small drawing room the empty blue bottle lay on the table beside the open reticule and the folded paper with its ruled-through column.

❦

Four drank from the glass before her and took no harm — so who put something in it, and why that Sunday?

The Inspector’s Brief → the solution, filed by Inspector Ulysses, the 9th of November The Pistols are laid to-day → the Colonel’s weekly observance of the armed table

Portraits by Dan Smith.